When upgrading a short-term rental, hosts often face a common question: Should I install a fire pit or a hot tub?

Both amenities are popular with guests, but they offer different benefits depending on the property, location, and budget.

Understanding how each feature impacts guest behavior can help hosts decide which investment makes the most sense.

Why Fire Pits Are So Popular

Fire pits create a cozy atmosphere that encourages guests to gather and relax outdoors.

They’re relatively affordable and easy to install, making them a common choice for property owners.

Benefits include:

• Lower installation cost
• Simple maintenance
• Strong visual appeal in listing photos
• Great for group gatherings

Fire pits are particularly popular for properties that emphasize outdoor experiences.

Why Hot Tubs Drive Bookings

Hot tubs are often considered a premium amenity in vacation rentals.

Guests frequently search for properties specifically offering hot tubs, making them a powerful booking driver.

Advantages include:

• Higher nightly rates
• Strong appeal for couples and groups
• Year-round usability
• Increased listing visibility through amenity filters

Because of this, many hosts see hot tubs as one of the most impactful vacation rental upgrades that increase bookings.

Which One Is Better?

The answer depends on the property and the target guests.

Fire pits are ideal for:

• Budget-conscious upgrades
• Outdoor gathering spaces
• Larger properties with scenic surroundings

Hot tubs are ideal for:

• Luxury vacation rentals
• Romantic getaways
• Competitive markets

Some hosts choose to include both amenities for maximum appeal.

Final Thoughts

Both fire pits and hot tubs can improve a property’s performance. The right choice depends on budget, location, and guest expectations.

For hosts looking to maximize revenue, thoughtful STR property improvement services can make a significant difference in bookings and guest satisfaction.